NYT Maureen Dowd Kicked Off McCain’s Campaign Plane: He’s ‘Dismissive of 1st Amend’
-By Warner Todd Huston
Well, I guess the McCain campaign really did get tough on the New York Times. Yesterday, leftist columnist Maureen Dowd was told she was no longer welcome on McCain’s campaign plane and had to go home with her tail between her legs. Tim McNulty of the Pittsburgh Post Gazette reports that Mo’s parting shot was a charge that because of this incident McCain is somehow against the First Amendment like she imagines Dick Cheney is.
Rather amusingly, she was dumped in the middle of Pennsylvania, too. After an August 30 rally in Washington, PA, she was told she could not get back on the plane. The rest of the press corps loaded up and off they flew leaving poor Mo standing there in shock.
Naturally, instead of seeing this as just deserts, Dowd goes on to blame everyone else.
“It was disappointing because I didn’t think John McCain would ever be as dismissive of the First Amendment as Dick Cheney.”
Sorry, Mo, but you shouldn’t expect to be welcomed with open arms while you constantly have your knife out, stabbing wildly like you do. McCain is NOT president yet, so he really doesn’t have to suffer your odious presence if he doesn’t want to.
Let’s face it, Dowd is not a journalist. She is an opinion editorialist. She does not report, she opines. She simply cannot be expected to present unbiased news. McCain knows that he cannot even breathe without Dowd calling it a crime against humanity so that makes her a perfectly legitimate target for dismissal. There is just no expectation of fairness with a Maureen Dowd. Everyone knows it.
If more campaigns did this to media types that merely express opinions as opposed to reporting what is going on with the campaign one might expect that we’d get more serious news as opposed to constant personal opinion.
And, lastly, Dowd is wildly overstating her predicament. She is in no way whatever having her First Amendment rights curtailed. No one said she isn’t allowed to write and publish whatever she feels. But there is no “right,” Constitutional or otherwise, to be on a candidate’s press plane.
So, good on ya, John McCain. But, as a writer myself, let me say one thing. This sort of action by the McCain camp is justified in this case, but such actions really must be used sparingly lest a real dampening of the First Amendment occur. Limits are good and right when they are justified. Abuse is not.
(Photo credit: www.observer.com)
Email This
Posted by Warner Todd Huston on October 2, 2008 10:06 am
» Filed Under 1st Amendment, Democrats, Elections, Liberal Media/Bias, News
Trackback URL:
- America Needs Me » Dowd In The Dumps pinged this post.
- Maureen Dowd’s “Odious Presence” No Longer Welcome On McCain’s Plane « Blog Entry « Dr. Melissa Clouthier pinged this post.
- Poor Mo Dowd, Kicked Off The McCain Plane » Pirate’s Cove — Barracuda Patrol! pinged this post.
- Steynian 261 « Free Mark Steyn! pinged this post.
- No Runny Eggs » Blog Archive » The Morning Scramble - The Glorious And Late Return - 10/3/2008 pinged this post.
Comments
4 Responses to “NYT Maureen Dowd Kicked Off McCain’s Campaign Plane: He’s ‘Dismissive of 1st Amend’”
-
-
-
Affiliations
The Giants
Advertise
-
-
Our Store
- Click the design to visit our store and help Stop the ACLU!
-
- More blogs about the ACLU
Syndicate Me
She also needs to get a better understanding of the Constitution. The first amendment says, “Congress shall make no law “. What law was made to prohibit her speech? None. Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences. Yes you can be fired or kicked off a plane for your speech. You cannot be charged criminally. If she wants, she can file a civil lawsuit against him.
Heh heh. Glad I looked, cause I was going to cross post the same thing
Way to go, McCain! *applause*
“It was disappointing because I didn’t think John McCain would ever be as dismissive of the First Amendment as Dick Cheney.”
Really, I thought McCain was just dismissive of irritating shrews.
Truth be told, Dowd should just be glad she wasn’t kicked off the plane while it was in the air.
In my humble opinion, Dowd should be fired. I have never read anything that she wrote that made every day common sense to the average american. Of coarse you can say that about all the NYT Op Ed writers. They must all belong to the ACLU.